April 13, 2006
Hattie McDaniel: Mama FeelGood
by John Calendo
“Hell, I’d rather play a maid than be one.”
— Hattie McDaniel

Hattie McDaniel gets her stamp“That’s Hattie McDaniel,” the Indian woman working the counter at the Post Office told me when she showed me my choice of stamps. “George Clooney mentioned her last night at the Oscars. She was the first black woman to …”

Yes, I knew — to get the Oscar. And I knew also what Clooney hadn’t mentioned:

When McDaniel picked up her award for Best Supporting Actress, she was the first black woman to ever set foot in the Coconut Grove who wasn’t behind a serving tray and that even in progressive, Jewish-humanitarian Hollywood, Hattie had to make her long walk to stage from the darkest, farthest, most removed part of the restaurant, the very back, practically the coat-check room.

Hattie McDaniel is one of many reasons — some of the others are Vivien Leigh, Olivia de Haviland, Butterfly McQueen — that Gone With the Wind can never be remade. Her Oscar-winning Mammy was big, bossy, formidable, warning the teenage Scarlett to finish her vittles before she went out:

“I done told you and told you, you can always tell a lady by the way she eats in front of people like a bird. And I ain’t aimin’ to have you go over to Mista John Wilkes’ house and eat like a field hand and gobble like a hog” — going basso profundo on that word hog.

Mammy at the windowBut it wasn’t only the written script. It was her deep-voiced, orchestrated Negro phrasing of what seemed like ad-libbed interjections: “Ain’t fittin! Ain’t fittin …” Pausing for the right syncopation, finding it: “Ain’t fittin!”

A later generation criticized her for playing maids and mammys — “female Uncle Tom’s.” “What did you want me to do?” she replied in exasperation. “Play a glamor girl and sit on Clark Gable’s knee?”

It was 1940, after all. She was, as she herself proclaimed, “always lucky.” And in an America where she was one of perhaps three public black faces, everything she did or said had to “uplift the race.” Gooder than good. Carrying the whole people on her motherly back.

Still Hattie knew how to have fun, to the tune of four husbands, a grand Hollywood house and that flirtatious rustle of the red petticoat she showed off with a giggle in an unforgettable GWTW moment. She was, in a strange way, white Hollywood’s penance for what Edward Albee recounts in his play The Death of Bessie Smith. The bluesy big-bodied Bessie died outside of an emergency room, right there on the pavement, when a whites-only hospital in Mississippi refused to treat her after a car accident.

Hattie was big Bessie reborn. “That’s a powerful lucky rabbit’s foot I got, ” McDaniel said of snagging the role in GWTW. And now here she was in my hand, on a U.S. stamp.

I write this because her story resonates with me as a gay man. The black struggle for civil rights leads and prefigures our own struggle. The details are different, the discrimination more instant, more total. But the discrimination against gay people has been sharp enough. Some of our lives have been shrunk by it, and some of our lives have carried on regardless. But we too have died under it.

The red petticoatIt’s a comparison that seems obvious — except to many black people, who have failed to draw the universal, rather than the particular, lesson from their passage into the mainstream. Hattie McDaniel was their herald, their scout into a rich, menacing frontier. And in an oblique way, she was ours as well.

Rita Dove, a Poet Laureate during the Clinton years and herself a back woman, remembers Hattie’s long walk to the Oscar stage in a poem she wrote for her latest volume American Smooth:

“Hattie McDaniel arrives at the Coconut Grove late,” the poem begins, “in aqua and ermine.” The actress has gardenias on her sleeve and “stars and rhinestones clipped to her brilliantined hair.” Dove calls out the names of the maids she has played: “Beulah & Berta & Malena & Carrie & Violet & Cynthia & Fidlia.” And a few lines later, her iconic role: “Dear Mammy we can’t help but hug you, crawl into your generous lap.”

The closing lines sum up the longer walk out of Kansas City that got McDaniel to the Coconut Grove in the first place:

Three million dishes
a truckload of aprons and headrags later, and here
you are: poised, between husbands
and factions, no corset wide enough
to hold you in, your huge face a dark moon split
by that spontaneous smile — your trademark,
your curse. No matter, Hattie: It’s a long beautiful walk
into that flower-smothered standing ovation,
so go on
and make them wait.
©2006 Nightcharm

Filed under: At the Movies |  Gay Politics |  Showbiz |
5 Responses to 'Hattie McDaniel: Mama FeelGood'
  1. Neil remarks:

    Thank you for this about Hattie. I loved her as a child already along with Louise Beavers and Ethel Waters. Growing up in Manhattan it took awhile until I knew and completely understood the dynamic of racism in America as this didn’t exist in my family or immediate circle, not so that I sensed anything. A child is taught prejudice from the society, as there was none at home I experienced none in my heart. My distress as I grew into reality was great along with my disallusionment as I comprehended the ever double standard in the so called Free, Democratic American society. These women were not maids and second class citizens in my young eyes but symbols of warmth, love, humour, and true honest emotions often exressing more wisdom than ever came out of a white persons mouth. The represented a level of compassion that I more often experienced among black people in reality than ever among my own.


    April 13th, 2006 at 10:31 am
  2. Lucas remarks:

    I have read your story and I am happy to find the sentence, “The details are different, the discrimination more instant, more total”. Although I would have preferred that you expound on that distinction more; I will just have to appreciate that you did not make the same mistake as earlier writers. So many writers have equated their own struggles to black men and women living in America. They have sited examples of hatred, violence, lack of respect and apathy but do not talk about how those scars uniquely affect black men and women. Instead they take the position, “Since I have experienced this pain then I understand your pain”. This position shows the writer’s arrogance rather than their compassion. Those writers intend on building bridges but end up building walls. Again I am happy to see you did not make the same mistake.

    Lucas from TX.


    April 13th, 2006 at 1:25 pm
  3. Jack Sharney remarks:

    I loved your article about Hattie McDaniel. I remember her well from her radio program and I remember the night it was announced that she had passed away. I remember crying for losing her. She was a wonderful part of my childhood from those radio days. Yes I am that old that I remember her program called “Beulah”
    I did not grow up with racism in my home so I never
    understood why others said such nasty things about the
    African Americans. It was very confusing and I am still
    confused that it is still going on in our country.
    As for the gays fighting for their civil rights, I too understand that as well. I am of the Jewish faith, have
    been called horrible names as a Jewish person and also
    as a gay male. I have a double whammy on me. I could
    use old Mammy for a hug and I wish she was here so I could hug her as a PERSON, not as a maid or a black woman, but a PERSON.
    Jack


    April 13th, 2006 at 5:27 pm
  4. demetrius remarks:

    Great work JC. And kudos for speaking on this without need from a particular headline or such. Definitely are some men of color reading, and enjoying, this continually great site.

    Cheers to new days and ways!


    April 13th, 2006 at 6:21 pm
  5. Tom remarks:

    Thanks John - a beautiful and thoughtful tribute that gently touches on our own situation without weighing either of them down or making one less relevant than the other. Inspired and inspiring writing. Thank you!


    April 13th, 2006 at 7:14 pm

Leave a Reply


Fuck Buddies
Hot Cartoon Cock
Hot Cartoon Cock
Gay Sex Magic
Naked Gay Frat Guys

Nightcharm

Brit journalist Mark Simpson, father of the term metrosexual, calls Nightcharm.com the "thinking onanist's website." We think that's an objective description of what we're about. For the past ten years Nightcharm has delivered the best in naked men pictures, high octane gay erotica and bang-up blogging on gay sexuality, art, film, music and queer pop culture. Our free gay blog is supported by memberships to our hardcore porn site The Inner Circle. If what you like up front makes you want to do something nasty in the back, please consider becoming a member today.

NIGHTCHARM | EMAIL | LINKS | MODEL FOR US | WRITE FOR US

18 USC 2257 Record-Keeping Requirements Compliance Statement regarding models appearing on this website.

All content copyright © 2008 Nightcharm, Inc.