May 17, 2008
I Love You (But Not That Way): Man Crush Confidential
by Shawn Baker

“I just wanna hang out with him so bad, man! Why won’t he call?!”

You’ve got a Man Crush: the state of not actually being gay… just gay for somebody in particular, as in “Dude, you’re totally gay for him.”

It’s a hetero thing.

On the evolutionary scale of gaydom, it’s the emotional spin-off equivalent of Joanie Loves Chachi to our Happy Days: a goofy simulacrum, a jejune take-off, a wacky send-up. Never daring enough to vie the NC-17 and too coy to go full-frontal, it plays like a G-rated apery of the real deal.

Its exact inception is impossible to pinpoint. Historically, the very moment that a man was first esteemed and thus set apart from his peers based on his physical prowess would have been the stone’s throw that commenced the ripple effect down the ages.

The primeval hominid who struck a spark with his flint or felled a mastodon no doubt drew his fair share of admiring tribesmen and exalted cave paintings immortalizing his exploits.

Gladiators — the prototype for modern-day pro athletes — prevailed the literal and figurative laurels from the crowd.

Dashing silent film star Wallace Reid may very well be the first man to lay claim to being Hollywood’s premier dreamboat.

Less due to genuine gonad-triggered upsurges than subconscious wish fulfillment, the Man Crush runs on idolatry, hero worship, a projected narcissism, and a vicarious desire to blur personalities (or, more accurately, personae). There still remains a hairsbreadth of overlap in the two emotions.

Gender-bender Jackie Curtis memorably opined “Well we all have a little dyke in us” in Paul Morrissey’s Women in Revolt, the implication being that complete and total hetero or homo status can never be confirmed. It’s possible that every confirmed bachelor has at least one female (usually an icon or celebrity) that stirs a slight pitter-patter in his heart due to her public recognition or glamor, while even the most debonair lady killer is destined to be once bitten, twice shy when he encounters another man who can best him at his own game.

Gayness is wanting to experience being with another man; the Man Crush centers around just being him.

James Dean was known to nurse an intense fascination with Marlon Brando, boasting he possessed that fabled snapshot of Brando with a cock in his mouth and keeping it as a sort of talisman to summon up his fetish figure’s mystique. Dean would manage to move into a New York apartment once occupied by Brando and speculated excitedly on the object of his adulation’s sexual encounters that took place there.

In turn, Steve McQueen harbored a consuming-if-resentful fixation on Dean, so much so that he confessed relief upon his idol’s untimely demise. With Dean out of the way, McQueen believed he was now free to take his place.

Don’t-you-wish-you-could-be-me? heartthrobs George Clooney and Tom Brady (now canonized as one of the most potent jujus in all idol-worship: the action figure) are the current favored Meta-Men, but the boys’ club that is the political arena isn’t immune to the pangs of the Man Crush.

Benevolent overlord and all-around man’s man’s George Bush has flirted with no less than four high-profile crushes during his reign, playing the love object in his stuck-on-you captivations of buddy-boys Joe Lieberman and Tony Blair, then going all doe-eyed during his infatuated idylls with Euro-swains Vladimir Putin and Nicolas Sarkozy.

Virtually every cross-section of the hetero world plays on the same tango, the hitch being that it’s an inherently unequal dance wherein only one man leads. The Desired has the power, the Desirer covets it. The Gym King with the biggest muscles is bound to have a gang of butch but not-quite-as Machistean followers who bolster his ego and crave his cred.

High-rolling money men with Bondian cavalcades of dispensable babes are apt to throw less prized fillies the way of their loyal yes-men. Athletes, actors and pop stars who hit the big time will inevitably bring with them an entourage of fair-weather male friends from the neighborhood who siphon off their glory while telling their fair-haired boy whatever he wants to hear.

Symbiosis is the name of the game: both sides of the Man Crush will benefit from one another’s company, be it having a mirror to adore yourself in or a idealized male exemplar to emulate and draw orbital respect from. Nature has the crocodile opening its maw to allow the plover bird to feast on parasites found on its teeth, while the Remora suckerfish will trail in a shark’s wake and feed of parasites living on the predator’s skin. A need is served as what would normally result in blood on the water manages to instead strike a fragile balance of shared convenience.

It’s a fragile equilibrium easily broken, though, one derailed by obsession or actual emotional attachment. Fight Club revealed the treacherous path wherein an egodystonic male actually becomes his cavalier fantasy alter self who then proceeds to transform into a Frankensteinian creation his dreamer can never hope to master.

And leave it to the peerless Buffy The Vampire Slayer — whose lovelorn and fucked-up monsters tapped into the queer vein at the heart of all young adults’ sexual urges — to etch the epitaph for a doomed Man Crush gone too far. In a comic apex for the series, the token gay member of the Slayer’s triumvirate of geek nemeses having been seduced and abandoned by his leader, loses his cool and nearly confesses a tearful gay heartbreak. His brilliant deadpan save to cover up the wistful near-slip: “He was just using me. He never really loved…hanging out with us!”

This power divide is key and the main reason why so few camaraderies and friendships form (much more, thrive) between an alpha straight male and an alpha gay one; a fit, confident and shrewd gay guy will balk at playing Robin to his pal’s Batman, and thus the roles are threatened. Alpha or Gamma gays engender resentment from straight males because they’re too resistant to passive corralling. Worse yet, even the most feared/respected hetero male will experience the anxiety of being challenged by his gay match. If the Alpha Gay has his own power and the will to wield it, the paranoia is that he may just decide to take what he believes he deserves. Asses will involuntarily clench at the thought.

Such is the benefit of any look-but-don’t-touch crush: its very distance allows for fantasy without ever leading to any of the perilous entanglements and troubling self-awareness that come with a true hormonal haymaker to the crotch and the heart.

©2008 Nightcharm

Bookmark and Share
Filed under: Psyche |  Studs |
13 Responses to 'I Love You (But Not That Way): Man Crush Confidential'
  1. Thorn remarks:

    Well, after that enjoyable mental workout, I feel like I need to hit the showers. Want to come?


    May 18th, 2008 at 4:39 am
  2. CURTIS remarks:

    Ummmm, I need a translation on the following, please if you don’t mind: “Its exact inception is impossible to pinpoint. Historically, the very moment that a man was first esteemed and thus set apart from his peers based on his physical prowess would have been the stone’s throw that commenced the ripple effect down the ages.The primeval hominid who struck a spark with his flint or felled a mastodon no doubt drew his fair share of admiring tribesmen and exalted cave paintings immortalizing his exploits.Gladiators — the prototype for modern-day pro athletes — prevailed the literal and figurative laurels from the crowd.”

    And, I think the choice of pictures wasn’t really the way to go, since by all accounts they both had homo sex with one or another men/actors/wannabes. So, that would really make them, well, gay? You need at least one of them to be straight, right?
    I’m really not being obtuse, I just am not sure where this article is wanting to take us, or tell us.
    Thanks, guys,
    ceg.


    May 18th, 2008 at 2:12 pm
  3. Gry remarks:

    Brando and Dean may’ve played on the gay side of the fence (probably for roles, like most young actors at the time), but I get the sense that they mainly had eyes for the ladies.

    The point of the above section is that societies idolize men for their strength and so other men want to emulate them. Today we have movie stars and athletes. It used to be gladiators and warriors.


    May 18th, 2008 at 3:28 pm
  4. David K. remarks:

    That’s a good point, Curtis, about our opening graphic. It is a bit (maybe) misleading.

    Truth be told I’m so smitten by the young Brando (to me the most gorgeous male that’s ever traversed our solar system) I just had to find a way to ‘play around’ with his image in Photoshop (”Lord ever near to thee”).

    James Dean I can take or leave, he was handsome, for sure, but seemed disconnected from his beauty. Not sure. Brando owned and worked his magic for all it was worth, with fabulous results. Dean I can see as ‘bi’, whereas Brando was just sex, as in ’sex before there were men and women on the planet.’ I guess that would be ’sex’ as the archetypal. AMEN.

    David K.
    Publisher


    May 18th, 2008 at 5:08 pm
  5. Jerry Weiss remarks:

    When James Dean was alive (and I’m old enough to have been there too) his nickname in the gay community was “the human ash tray.” Rock Hudson was “Mr. Coke Bottle.”
    (quart size).

    True? Bitchy hyperbole? We’ll never know.


    May 18th, 2008 at 6:51 pm
  6. Greta VanSnatchen remarks:

    HOW DISGUSTING! CANCEL MY MMEMBERSHIP NOW!!!!!


    May 18th, 2008 at 7:13 pm
  7. Thorn remarks:

    Greta, I am completely confused by your response. Just sayin’.


    May 19th, 2008 at 9:17 am
  8. chriso remarks:

    I think it’s funny that you mention both James Dean and George Clooney since rumors about the first have always been that he’s at least bi and I’ve been hearing stories that George is gay for forever.


    May 20th, 2008 at 12:31 pm
  9. Miyah Lance remarks:

    It is sad for people who think that they is gay because they only gentle. That is why the word ‘gentle man’ come out from anyway. You can’t put a square potato in a round bowl. Sometimes it take a lady.


    May 21st, 2008 at 6:22 am
  10. chriso remarks:

    Miyah Lance, I want the drugs you’re on. They seem fun.


    May 21st, 2008 at 12:53 pm
  11. mountii remarks:

    What about Carl Rove, I know Carl had it a good time with Bush, no really I’m serious, I saw a doc where it potrayed Carl as always longing to work for Bush

    U be the judge on that one


    May 21st, 2008 at 1:34 pm
  12. Nicky Shame remarks:

    wow. stunningly real.


    May 21st, 2008 at 6:45 pm
  13. Flick remarks:

    Chris Matthews had it bad for Bush for a long time. I think he must’ve had a raging hard-on during the “Mission Accomplished” farce when Bushie came out in his G.I. Joe get up and codpiece.

    That’s why the administration and the military used all the fake PR to spin Pat Tillman’s death. They needed a handsome and square jawed face to put on the war to get the hearts of the Neocon base all fluttery.


    May 21st, 2008 at 10:14 pm

Leave a Reply


Twitter
Hot Cartoon Cock
Hot Cartoon Cock
New Pricing
Naked Gay Frat Guys

Nightcharm

Brit journalist Mark Simpson, father of the term metrosexual, calls Nightcharm.com the "thinking onanist's website." We think that's an objective description of what we're about. For the past ten years Nightcharm has delivered the best in naked men pictures, high octane gay erotica and bang-up blogging on gay sexuality, art, film, music and queer pop culture. Our free gay blog is supported by memberships to our hardcore porn site The Inner Circle. If what you like up front makes you want to do something nasty in the back, please consider becoming a member today.

NIGHTCHARM | EMAIL | LINKS | MODEL FOR US | WRITE FOR US

18 USC 2257 Record-Keeping Requirements Compliance Statement regarding models appearing on this website.

All content copyright © 2009 Nightcharm, Inc.